Bad Ems is one of the few classic courses in Germany that have preserved their old style character. Despite extensive renovations it still looks, feels and plays like a Golden Age layout. It certainly must be considered a rarity that the two recently introduced lakes look like they belong and even improve on the hole strategies.

The routing moves about quite resolutely, but there are no longer walks between the holes with the possible exception of a pleasant, albeit uphill stroll through the woods between #15 and #16. However, on the holes themselves the undulations come fully into play, there is hardly a level stance to be had. The terrain and the green complexes are challenging enough, so there has never been a need for elaborate bunkering and that may constitute the main difference to a Tom Simpson course (Bad Ems was erroneously attributed to him by Cornish & Whitten).

Although the site is heavily wooded, the playing corridors are wide enough and the soil, while not heathery, is quite good as a result. Drama, excitement and strategic interest are all there, as is the variety that will keep a layout fresh for the members. It even tries to play firm and fast, which certainly succeeds for the greens. Fortunately there is no room for lengthening the holes, so hopefully no one will try to bring the former venue of the German Open up to "modern standards". As it is, the course is loads of fun to play for the average golfer and all but the very best players should find it plenty challenging as well.